search results only link to the post not the thread

Last post 09-25-2008, 12:55 PM by sirwally. 1 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  06-11-2007, 5:56 14829

    search results only link to the post not the thread

    when using the search, the list of results are just links to the individual post, so you don't see the entire thread to get the full context of the post

     i can click the link above the individual post once i've got there to then get the whole thread but i think it would be better to originally link to the thread but get the page opening at the post referred to in the search result (as per the old forums)

    edit: i've also tried the threaded view when the post appears but this doesn't seem to work very well

  •  09-25-2008, 12:55 PM 26329 in reply to 14829

    Re: search results only link to the post not the thread

    I concur with this.  While the "View Complete Thread" link at the bottom left will take you to where you probably want to be (at least, that's where I want to be) I don't think I have ever seen another forum system that works this way.  IMHO the problem is larger, because there is a very good chance that a search will actually yield far more results that necessary in because multiple responses within a thread are returned.  If I get 10 results, and 5 of them are to the same thread, this isn't all that useful.  I wouldn't be surprised if a large number of users do what I do and jump straight to the "View Complete Thread" before reading.  I prefer to see the response in context, because without that the response is of questionable value.

    Just my opinion...I could be wrong (again ;-)

View as RSS news feed in XML